Immigration Update: Latest Changes to PERM Labor Certification





The Department of Labor has made significant structural and substantive changes to the employer-sponsored Application for Permanent Labor Certification process, and we are filling you in on the details! Both prospective green card applicants and sponsoring employers should benefit from this blog, as it is crucial for all involved to stay up to date with these developments.


Background on the Employer-Sponsored Green Card Process


Before we delve into the updates, let’s briefly recap this particular employer-sponsored green card process. An Application for Permanent Labor Certification (also known as PERM or labor certification) is a preliminary green card step designed for foreign workers who receive a full-time job offer from a U.S. employer and wish to pursue permanent employment opportunities in the country. Unlike some other applications filed directly with the Immigration Service (USCIS), the PERM application is submitted on Form ETA-9089 for review by the U.S. Department of Labor’s Office of Labor Certification. As we covered in a previous detailed video on how to obtain an employer-sponsored green card, the first step in this process entails filing a prevailing wage request. At this stage, employers provide detailed information about the offered job, including job title, duties, required experience, and job location, through the Department of Labor’s Foreign Labor Application Gateway (FLAG) online portal. After a few months, the Department of Labor responds with a wage figure associated with the position in the area of intended employment, ensuring the sponsored foreign worker receives at least that amount in compensation.


PERM Application Submissions Through FLAG Portal


On May 15, 2023, the Department of Labor consolidated the filing process in a single platform and announced that PERM applications would no longer be submitted through the prior legacy online system but through the same FLAG portal where prevailing wage requests are uploaded. While this may seem like a minor administrative change, it has implications for both applicants and employers.


Revised Form ETA-9089


In addition to the change in online filing location, Form ETA-9089 was itself revised with some notable revisions detailed below. Keep in mind that this overview does not encompass all the changes but provides a glimpse into what you can expect.


1. Number of Employees on Payroll: The revised Form ETA-9089 in Section A, Question 14 requires employers to disclose the number of employees on their payroll in the area of intended employment and is meant to provide the Department of Labor with a better understanding of an employer’s workforce. This question, however, may need to be answered differently in situations where employees are required to travel to unanticipated client sites.


2. Dual Representation: Employers are now asked whether they have engaged an agent or attorney who also represents the sponsored foreign worker. This question aims to ascertain the nature of the PERM representation ensuring compliance with 20 CFR 656.12(b). However, it has already created confusion among immigration attorneys as to how to best answer this field when legal work includes the common and legitimate practice of representing both the employer and the employee.


3. Nature of Work Site and Family Relationship: The revised form requests details about the type of work site where the foreign worker will be employed. Employers must indicate if it’s the employer’s business premises, private household, or the employee’s private residence, clarifying the specific work environment. The form also splits one question found in the retired version of Form ETA-9089 pertaining to familial relationships into two separate questions found in the new form’s Section A, Questions 16 & 17 and is likely meant to assess whether any bias may have crept into the recruitment process.


4. Business Necessity Justification: In specific circumstances, such as when proficiency in a foreign language is required or preferred for performing job duties, the new form mandates the completion of an additional appendix. Employers must provide a business necessity justification, explaining why proficiency in a foreign language is crucial for the position. Similarly, when the job opportunity involves a combination of occupations, employers must justify the business necessity for this arrangement. Historically, business necessity justifications like foreign language requirements and positions involving a combination of occupations have triggered audits. With the new form explicitly demanding disclosure of these justifications from the outset, it remains to be seen whether the number of audits will increase or decrease.


5. Auto Population of Certain Fields: The new Form ETA-9089 will now be linked to the PERM case’s prior-issued prevailing wage determination in the FLAG system and will auto populate with certain information contained in Form ETA-9141.


Implications of the Changes


At this early stage, it is unclear as to how these new PERM applications will be adjudicated. If history is any predictor, they may be met with an initial wave of audits or improper rejections, as happened in 2005 when the current labor certification process transitioned over from its predecessor known as Reduction in Recruitment (RIR). While the integration of the PERM application into the FLAG system suggests an enhanced focus on efficiency and streamlining, the inclusion of additional requirements, such as providing business necessity justifications upfront and answering ambiguous questions regarding representation, may cause confusion and delays in processing.




Thank you for reading our blog detailing recent changes affecting the PERM process. Staying informed about these updates is vital for individuals seeking employer-sponsored green cards and employers interested in sponsoring foreign workers. While it’s too early to gauge the full impact of the changes, we will continue to monitor the situation closely and keep you informed. We appreciate your support and look forward to providing you with more empowering articles in the near future.

Share this post...

Ashoori Law
Based on 591 reviews
Jamal Albardwil
I was delighted with my experience. Mr. Ehsan Ashoori Was a professional, and free consultation meant free and informative. And he educated me on what to expect and do, the likely outcomes, and how to achieve it. I would highly highly recommend this... immigration law firm to anyone needing an immigration law firm.I wish I could give them 6 stars.100% more
Sanjeev Bhalla
Ashoori Law is a professional law firm with a great team. We had applied for my daughter's change of status visa and they handled it pretty well and we got the status change without any difficulty. I would strongly recommend them to anyone who... wishes to engage a immigration law firm. They will do a great job as was in our case. I'd like to thank Michael and Sergio as well their entire team for the fantastic work work they did for more
Graem Beddoes
Very grateful for the help and guidance in getting our E2
Carolina Marmolejo
Very proffessional law firm. My husband & I appreciated their attentive, meticulous and detailed work on our case. They always stayed communicated and responsive to us from beginning to end.
Kaveeta Ramnarine
Totally grateful to the Ashoori team for their excellent service. They are very responsive and knowledgeable, they go above and beyond for their clients.Special thank you to Attorneys Rebecca McCarthy and Ehsan Mehri for their continued support in... our more
Shyam Chandrasekharan
I wanted to express my heartfelt thanks for your exceptional guidance and expertise in securing my visa extension approval. Your professionalism, attention to detail, and dedication were instrumental in achieving this success. Your support and clear... communication throughout the process were invaluable. I'm deeply grateful for your outstanding more
Malia Hi’ilani
Ashoori Law is a very knowledgeable and thorough law firm, with a great team. They gave me confidence in my business plan by providing a free discovery call to see if it was worth pursuing. Very personable and available for all of my questions or... concerns throughout the process. I was granted my E2 change of status successfully. I would highly recommend them for all of your immigration more
Israt Jahan
AshooriLaw is a great choice for our case.they response fast and very helpful.
Beth Jinks
Ashoori Law again handled my green card travel document renewal application professionally, and they accurately predicted the processing time. I've tackled similar paperwork alone before, but have now been working with Ashoori for about five years... because they provide peace of mind that everything is handled correctly. Highly more
Chris Lejeune
At first I was hesitant hiring a lawyer from outside Texas that no one I knew personally dealt with however I am glad I did. These guys are very helpful and friendly. Their knowledge of my case and procedures was outstanding. 5 stars all day long.
Yuvraj Singh
I would highly recommend Ashoori law for any kind of immigration services. They are fast, their process is easy and they are professional. I would highly suggest them handle your immigration cases.
Mazen Hanana
Thank you for your amazing services as well as for your prompt response to all my queries.Your professional experience was very helpful in submitting, approving and getting my Re-entry permit
Very great! Love, love, love Ashoori Law and his team. They make you feel like family. This is the team that will definitely get the job done. Very friendly and professional!
Nyoka Bandoo
Very professional and looks out for your best interest at heart!
arsalan pervez
Hello sir u have watsap number
My wife & I recently engaged the services of Ashoori Law for Immigration services, and I must say that I am thoroughly impressed with their expertise and professionalism. From the moment I contacted them, they demonstrated a deep understanding of my... case and provided insightful advice that put me at ease. Their legal team, led by Micheal, displayed an exceptional grasp of the intricacies involved in my situation. The Ashoori Law team not only guided me through the entire legal process but also took the time to answer all my questions in a clear and concise manner. Their attention to detail and dedication to my case truly set them apart. I am pleased with the overall outcome and would recommend Ashoori Law for their top-notch legal more
Before contacting Michael Ashoori's firm, I had spoken to a few Immigration lawyers, NONE was as patient and responsive as Michael. His firm scheduled a call with an Attorney who turned out to be the most efficient and brilliant lawyer ever.... Stephanie DiPietro was simply amazing. The detail in her notes, cover letter and crisp responses to my plentiful enquires mostly done with a smile was always reassuring. I highly recommend this firm as they are worth much more than they more
I had an exceptional experience with Ashoori Law. I hired Ashoori Law Firm to help with my immigration process. They assigned me a dedicated legal assistant, Jeser, and an attorney, Matthew, to guide me through the process. I am truly grateful for... the responsiveness of Jeser and Matthew. They consistently answered all my questions and helped me prepare all the documents for the application. The team's friendliness and remarkable expertise stand out. I highly recommend Ashoori Law to anyone seeking legal services for more
Anas Khan
Michael's firm has been very helpful in processing, filing and taking the Re-entry permit to its successful approval. I needed help as I had to travel due to personal emergency for an extended duration and had a lot of questions with no time to... think. They gave us time and clarified all the questions over call, email giving proper directions. Some of the videos on YouTube posted by Michael also helped me figure out that I could reach out to them to take my application forwardThanks to Matthew, Clara, Milena and all the folks who more
Alyssa Sanders
I highly recommend this lawyer for all immigration needs. They were so extremely patient with my situation and my questions, and definitely legitimately cared about the experience had with them. Immigration can be a very difficult and scary... experience and they definitely offered peace of mind. Very Affordable for the quality of services provided. I would definitely use them again in the future and recommend for immigrantion law needsread more
Fauzia Usman
Thankyou so much Michael Ashoori and your Immigration Attorney Shruti Bali and all team member to help me process me and my family case of E2 Investor Visa. It took Approx. 10 months from Ontario Canada. I Never visit IN person to this Firm,... everything deal and process online. Ashoori Law serve Great Professional Service. Highly more
Sonia Rathour
Ashoori Law Firm has the most loyal Representatives and lawyers who really cares about their client. They always available to answer any question you have regarding your case and always give the best advise for your best.I got so lucky to have... immigration case in their more
Dinesh Perera
I am so glad I chose Ashoori Law for my E2 process. They handled my case professionally from start to finish. My circumstances were somewhat complicated and needed special attention in order to get me across the finish line. I must state that I was... extremely fortunate to have had Shruti as my attorney handling my case. She was always very responsive to all my questions and cleared my doubts in every instance. All documents were very carefully handled by her and checked over and over again prior to submission, which i believe is the key to getting the E2 approved. Thank you Michael, Shruti and the entire team for a professional and successful job more
Next Reviews
Michael Ashoori Headshot

Michael Ashoori, Esq.

President of Ashoori Law

I’m a U.S. immigration lawyer and I help families, professionals, investors, and entrepreneurs get visas, green cards, and citizenship to the United States.

Since starting my law firm, I’ve helped hundreds of people from all over the world with their immigration needs. I’m very passionate, hard-working, and committed to my clients.

Got a question? Send me an email.